Least and Most: Greetings From Asbury Park, N.J

Am I really kicking off a new series? Is it another Springsteen-focused run? You betcha.

This shouldn’t be as time consuming to write or read as previous though. The idea is a pretty simple one: Bruce has twenty studio albums – discounting archival boxsets and karaoke soul cover albums – and having recently spent time running through the lot of ’em I’m gonna be picking two tracks from each, the most and least played / loved / enjoyable from my perspective. Granted, with so many five star albums in the mix it’ll be easier with some than others but that’s part of the ‘game’, right?

Spending time with Springsteen’s catalogue again recently I’ve noticed how my appreciation of certain albums has changed over the years and his 1973 debut Greetings From Asbury Park, N.J. is one of those that’s grown in my appreciation.

Adding an unbridled sense of exuberance to Dylan style thesaurus-wrestlers with exaggerated imagery and street scenes, Springsteen’s debut sets folk-based tunes to an electric band backing. This phase of Springsteen’s career was short-lived. The coffee-shop folkie mode he’d shifted to after Steel Mill seemed to have run its course even with Bruce for as soon as he’d signed as a solo artist he assembled a band again to cut his first album – which was also the first and only time he wrote complete lyrics before the music.

It’s pretty hard to identify lesser tracks from Springsteens early albums (early as he’s now into his sixth decade of releasing them) but ….

Least: The Angel

‘The Angel’ is such a slight, seemingly ineffective song that you’d pretty much forget it after hearing the album. It’s only been performed live twice. Ever.

Meanwhile there’s a wealth of great songs on here that stand up to constant repeating. Whether it’s the radio ‘hits’ – ‘Spirit In The Night’ and ‘Blinded By The Light’ – that he was sent to write after handing in an album that Columbia felt lacked any or the familiar ‘Growin’ Up’ and ‘For You’, these early nuggets are as golden as they get. For me, though, there’s one that stands head and shoulders above the rest…

Most: Lost In The Flood

It’s epic. It’s ridiculously well-written and arranged for a dude of 23 and has remained a fan favourite and crowd pleaser since. There was talk that Steven Van Zandt had a hand in creating some of the song’s sounds (particularly the explosion through the amp at kick-off) but he’s on record as denying that and there’s no mention in either Springsteen or SVZ’s* auto-bios. It’s one of those brooding, sparse story songs that Springsteen would smash out of the park throughout his career. Is is it his first Vietnam song? I think so… correct me if I’m wrong. Hell, I even had a ‘Bronx’s best apostle’ t-shirt for years my adoration of this song is so strong. It sits right in the middle of the running order but, to me, this is a key puzzle piece on the road to Born To Run and Darkness – it’s an underdog saga with just a small glimpse of hope.

To paraphrase El Duderino, though, this is just, like, my opinion, man. Let me know if you think I’m miles off.

*Reading Unrequited Infatuations it would seem Van Zandt was completely off Springsteen’s radar between his signing with and releasing his first two albums for Columbia as he wasn’t part of the band you get the impression he was having a little bit of a sulk about it.

Catch-up spins

It’s been a while since I was ‘here’ having pretty much taken most of summer off. It feels like a fitting way to get back up to speed with a review of what’s been going on in my ears over the past few months.

Air – Radio # 1

I spent a good chunk of time in France, again, this summer. Arriving in time to watch the Olympics’ closing ceremony from a hotel bed and marvel at – after hours of more pointless faff that rivalled the opening ceremony for fuckery – how wasted Air were. It did mean that I spent time in a number of Lyon record shops hunting for Air albums though and came home with their first trio. Following up the faultless Moon Safari was never going to be easy and while 10,000 Hz Legend wasn’t as successful or well-recieved I’ve always had a soft-spot for its willingness to experiment.

Soccer Mommy – Driver

It sounds like the upcoming new album from Soccer Mommy is a bit of a retreat from the production of 2022’s brilliant Sometimes, Forever to a more organic sound and I’m all on board for it.

The Cure – Alone

It seems strange that as we near the end of 2024 I’m still enjoying a new Pearl Jam record, I have pre-orders in place for new records by Smashing Pumpkins, Pixies and The Cure. On the one hand it’s akin to Pink Floyd and The Rolling Stones releasing new albums in 1994 which would’ve been pretty much unnoticed by the younger ears of the time, on the other hand I’m bloody loving the fact that so many of my favourites artists are still dropping records and that so many of them are hitting at the same moment. The wait for a new Cure album has been ridiculous but Song Of A Lost World is shaping up strong based on the two songs dropped thus far.

Girls In Hawaii – Flavor

Another album fittingly purchased while in France – the 20th Anniversary edition of Girls In Hawaii’s From Here to There, an album my wife and I listened to on repeat on our first holiday together some 16 years prior and soundtracked plenty of our driving around France at the time. While I’ve enjoyed some of their subsequent albums more, this Belgian band’s upbeat indie vibe is always a fun spin.

Kim Deal – A Good Time Pushed

In some ways it feels mad that we’re only getting a Kim Deal solo album in 2024 but given how many wonderful Pixies, The Breeders, Amps albums we’ve had it’s not like she’s been shirking. Given that she walked from working on new Pixies material it’s not too surprising just how sonically wide-reaching the sound of the songs released ahead of the album are.

Crowded House – Together Alone

I’ve been trying to listen to whole albums at a time again on my commute. Together Alone, the final of Crowded House’s first run of albums and still their finest, has popped up a couple of times. I adore this album’s sound and vibe especially the Maori choir and log drummers on this track.

Pearl Jam – Other Side

Anywho, here’s more Pearl Jam. As much as I’ve been enjoying Dark Matter since its release, I’ve been listening to tunes from their ‘lost’ era – Binaural and Riot Act – lately and Other Side, the other side to ‘Save You’, is a great tune that should’ve made the cut.

More midweek spinnage

Here we are once again at the midway point of the week with the scale starting to tip toward the weekend and, for me, the beginning of holiday season.

With that in mind, here’s what’s been going in the ears this week.

Smashing Pumpkins – Goeth The Fall

I don’t think I’ve enjoyed a new Smashing Pumpkins album in the way I have Aghori Mhori Mei in years. Released last week and heralded as one that’ll please the fans of the ’90s stuff and a ‘rock’ record, I’ve gotta say that’s about right. It’s not that good but I’ve been surprised how much I’ve been listening to it and enjoyed to the point of pre-ordering the vinyl.

Air – Kelly Watch The Stars (Edit Version)

While I’m not usually one for picture discs (especially overpriced RSD ones), when this one appeared in my local store’s sale it was an easy decision. Moon Safari is unimpeachable but getting this meant getting hold of the version that was played on MTV back in the day.

The Orb – Little Fluffy Clouds

With the exception of Smashing Pumpkins there seems to be a much more mellow edge to everything here. Maybe it’s the build up of CBD but that’s where I’m at lately. I actually caught this one on the radio this weekend and it’s gained a few spins since. I’ve also just discovered that it’s Rickie Lee Jones talking about clouds – the lads in The Orb heard her trippy response to “So what were the skies like when you were young?” in an interview (who the fuck asks that without smoking something first?) and sampled it. After paying her $5,000 for its use first.

Ben Howard – Time Is Dancing

Oh man I played this album so much when it came out I was surprised that the CD still held up when I chucked it in the car this week. It’s coming up for its tenth anniversary – with the prerequisite re-release in special colours / clear / etc – and for me marks the perfect point in Ben Howard’s sound; moving away from the ‘only love’ festival-pleasing acoustic work and embracing the more experimental elements that would enthuse the later albums while still retaining a focus song structure.

Pearl Jam – Force of Nature

Anyway, here’s some more Pearl Jam and another favourite deep(ish) cut from recent times. Backspacer is the only album I’m missing on my record shelves (for some reason it’s not as widely available as other albums) and while not my favourite it has some wonderful tunes on it and I love the shift in this song’s vibe.

It always gets so hard to see, right before the moon – Five from The War On Drugs

I know I’ve dropped a few tunes from The War on Drugs over the years here yet as I sit here with them in my ears through the day I figured it was time to drop a few more in one place in a more organised manner.

Originally formed when Kurt Vile and Adam Granduciel discovered their mutual obsession with Bob Dylan, the band dropped one album with that initial lineup before Vile’s departure to pursue his own solo career (on completely amicable terms) and a mass exodus of players led to Granduciel recruiting new members and gradually expanding on the band’s sound ahead of the release of 2014’s Lost In The Dream signified a massive shift in both their appeal and sound having arrived at a seemingly perfect combination of grand guitar-driven soundscapes that build and unfold into blissful tunes that combine obvious influences like Dylan and Petty with elements of My Bloody Valentines and Sonic Youth while retaining their own identity. From Lost In The Dream thru I Don’t Live Here Anymore they’d parlay this sound across three pretty-much faultless albums (so far) that inevitably occupy plenty of car stereo time as well as so often proving a mainstay in headphones as the sound manages to feel suited both to the intimate listen as well as creating a sensation of cruising down a clear highway at sunset.

A Needle In Your Eye #16

Debut albums are funny things when looked back on so many years later. Wagon Wheels is very much and album of 2008’s indie-rock feel and more heavily indebted to Vile and Granduciel’s love of Dylan than anything else with the band’s name on. While there’s plenty to enjoy Only ‘A Needle In Your Eye #16’ (I’m guessing the numbering of songs as ‘versions’ is another nod to Bob) is a real standout for me .

Brothers

Originally a longer tune on the Future Weather EP the version on second album Slave Ambient manages to retain the song’s vibe but bringing it into a tighter arrangement that – like a lot of songs on the album including the wonderful ‘Come to the City’ – feel like a clear transition is underway as Granduciel refines his sound.

An Ocean In Between The Waves

One of many highlights from 2014’s Lost In The Dream

Pain

A Deeper Understanding is another of those albums I can cue up and just let… flow. Adding a little more grit to the tone of Lost In The Dream, I love the sound of the guitars across the album and ‘Pain’ builds to a point that just lets these go.

Victim

It would be daft to repeat the same formula over and over and so, just as A Deeper Understanding adds to Lost In The Dream‘s sound, 2021’s I Don’t Live Here Anymore still contains just as many long burn, slow builders while adding a few more electronic elements and drum loops into the mix, bright sounding synths and upbeat tempos all wrapped-up in a mix that highlights the ‘morning in America’ era FM sound that manages to sound both reverential and fresh. There’s also plenty of lush guitar tones and scorchers too.

Another midweek spinnage

Slipping seamlessly into the middle of another week with an eye firmly on the approaching weekend like a desert oasis…. here’s another selection of those tunes that have been gaining traction this week.

Pixies – Chicken

As the Pixies prepare to drop album ten (with bass player number four) The Night The Zombies Came, I’ve been thoroughly enjoying the vibe of the single (do they still call it that? Is asking ‘do they still call it that?’ a signifier that I’m old?) they released this week, it’s a little different to their usual flavour but, as with the vast majority of things Frank Black, I’m here for it.

Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers – First Flash of Freedom

I’ve been giving Mojo a good bit of attention recently. I didn’t when it came out but after a few tracks came up on shuffle I’ve lined the whole album up for my commute a couple of times and while there are a few duds (someone really needed to have nuked ‘Don’t Pull Me Over’), if you trim those out there’s a more concise and close-to-perfect album there. The blues-based, jammier style they tapped into for their last pair of albums fitted them perfectly.

Muna – Anything But Me

Sitting there waiting for a tire to be changed the other day I caught a tune on the radio that I could’ve sworn I knew. It was this, and I did – having enjoyed their self-titled album in 2022 but failing to have listened much beyond that until hearing it again this last week. Sometimes there’s just so much to listen to that I feel more slips through the cracks than gets the attention it deserves. I think I read that Muna‘s singer has got a solo record about to drop too.

Slowdive – Cath The Breeze

Slowdive’s gorgeous 1991 debut Just For A Day – pressed on a nice translucent red marble vinyl – arrived in the post on Monday and I’ve since been covering myself in a lush blanket of shoegaze.

David Gilmour – The Piper’s Call

Due to arrive in the post at some point in the second half of this year, David Gilmour’s upcoming album Luck and Strange is touted as taking a different approach in production values with younger hands at the helm that weren’t in thrall to his legacy and the ‘deluxe’ sound that’s been slapped on all things Gilmour / Floyd since the ’90s. ‘The Piper’s Call’ is a pretty strong tune and Gilmour’s guitar, as always, is definitely worth tuning in for.

Mdou Moctar – Oh, France

Two thoughts here. One: I haven’t seen Mdou Moctar’s fucking PHENOMENAL Funeral for Justice in any where enough mentions for ‘best albums of the year so far’ conversations and B: I’m heading off to France for a couple of weeks in a couple of weeks – timed to slip between the Olympics and hopefully avoid too much faff. Three: this song is a fucking belter.

Pearl Jam – In Hiding

Anyway, here’s some Pearl Jam. ‘In Hiding’ is one of those beloved deep cuts for me – while my battles with the black dog of depression continue it’s lines like ‘No longer overwhelmed and it seems so simple now, it’s funny when things change so much it’s all state of mind’ to a tune like this that help me up just enough.

Midweek Spinnage

Been a while… again. Without further mumbling, it feels like a good ‘get over the mid-week slump’ exercise to share half a dozen of those things that’ve been getting into my ears this last week or so.

Wilco – Either Way

I’ve been slowly but shortly putting together and whittling down a list of what I would consider to be 100 albums that are essential to me – in a way revisiting a list I put together some sixteen years ago. I haven’t mentioned them much here, if it all, but Wilco are a wonderful band and their Sky Blue Sky is definitely on that list. It’s easily their finest album and I love this tune especially.

Gary Clark Jr – Bright Lights

Listening to the iPod on shuffle in the car can often mean a few tracks get skipped but whenever a tune from Gary Clark Jr’s Live comes on I’ll end up turning shuffle off and lining up the full album. I’ve been spending more time with his studio discography lately and his 2011 Bright Lights EP is a favourite and this is a hell of an earworm.

Larkin Poe – Preachin’ Blues

Across the summer, the park behind my house hosts a number of festivals and concerts. This weekend past was the ‘Maid in Stone’ festival which veered towards the hard rock / metal crowd. On our usual evening walk on Sunday, the cub and I were lucky enough to get there just as Larkin Poe kicked off their set and so sat under a tree a few yards from the stage – while not within the festival grounds – and got to enjoy a solid slab of the great stuff.

The National – Fake Empire

I added Boxer to the vinyl shelves this weekend (in a nice yellow hue) and hearing this made me harken back to a time that – while not all that long ago – seems like a lifetime ago in terms of political news from a former colony.

Bruce Springsteen – Rockaway the Days

This year marks the fortieth anniversary of Springsteen’s monster Born In The USA. Understandably, given how he’s since shared his dissatisfaction with the grab-bag nature of it, if not sadly, we’re not getting anything to celebrate the milestone beyond a coloured version of the record with a few extra photos in the liner. No The Promise or Ties That Bind revisit. Which is a shame for, as I’ve already covered in a three-parter, there were multiple versions of the album and a bounty of songs that were recorded and discarded before the final album emerged. While getting those out into the air wouldn’t necessarily cause a reevaluation of the album, it would certainly be great to get them all collected into one place and show that the scale of Springsteen’s vision at the time went far beyond the twelve tracks that kickstarted his Rambo era of stadium domination.

Pearl Jam – Wishing Well

They may have cancelled their London show at the last minute but I’m still spinning Pearl Jam on any day ending in ‘y’. This cover – from 2015’s Christmas single – has cropped up a few times lately and is still worth a listen.

You better, you better take cover: Post-Rock (Mondays) from Down Under

Despite all our fervent entreaties to various fictional deities, Monday is upon us. For me that always means working to a post-rock soundtrack. I’ve recently added one of the genre’s high points to my collection with We Lost The Sea’s Departure Songs. As it winged its way to my record shelves via Australia Post (BandCamp is a wonderful thing) I thought it a good opportunity to spin the eye of this blog momentarily onto that country’s offerings.

Once again I’ve turned to the internet to come up with a definition of post-rock and, once again, it continues to amuse: “Post-rock is rock music transcending itself – a form of creative freedom that looks within rather than without.Instead of exuberant frontmen and women, we’re confronted by shy, often sad-looking artistes, more at ease in the solitude of a recording studio rather than in front of an audience who love their music.

Audacious experimentation requires introspection and staying away from the loud, chaotic lifestyle that for decades was the epitome of rock music. And because of that, post-rock bands introduced a new way to experience this genre, one centred on the individual and their deepest emotions.”

Crikey.

We Lost The Sea – Challenger Part 2 – A Swan Song

Departure Songs, to quote the band is “inspired by failed, yet epic and honourable journeys or events throughout history where people have done extraordinary things for the greater good of those around them, and the progress of the human race itself.” It’s a beautiful album and this is a gorgeous final track.

Sleepmakeswaves – Perfect Detonator

Changing gears with Sydney’s Sleepmakeswaves. They have a new album that’s about to drop but Love of Cartography (which, shockingly has just turned ten years old) remains a favourite both in terms of its tunes, title and cover art. Australia Post should be setting a copy my way imminently as my CD copy has suffered an unfortunate fate.

Meniscus – Simulation

Hard-hitting, sweeping, tender… and all in one song. Meniscus’ Refractions album was a few years back now but is always worth a listen.

iiah – 20.9%

iiah have seemingly called it a day. Which is a shame as their last album Terra was exactly the kind of filmic stuff with a nod to the cosmos I love.

Bear the Mammoth – Freshwater

I’m not gonna lie; sometimes it’s the name that gets me listening. That was definitely the case with Melbourne’s Bear the Mammoth but I stayed listening the tunes and, particularly, the drums.

Tracks: Telegraph Road

YouTube and its algorithm are pretty confident that I want to see seemingly every ‘The Late Show’ guest’s answers to that show’s Colbert Questionert. While puzzling over why an audience seems to whoop and applaud someone’s take on the ‘best sandwich’ is one way to pass the minutes that make up a dull day, the one that makes me wonder is “you only get one song to listen to for the rest of your life: what is it?” The idea that if you could only listen to one song – not all the time, mind, just that if you go to listen to music it will only be this song – is tougher for some than others.

In a way this occasionally picked up, more often forgotten series ‘Tracks’ is my way of highlighting those songs that mean enough to me to probably wind up on a short list. I suppose that I’d want it to be a good long song with lots of parts and yet manages to sustain your ear and pleasure throughout. One that hits both an emotional collection as well as being just a bloody good song. Something, perhaps, like Dire Straits’ ‘Telegraph Road’. I’m not saying that if I were to ever be asked ‘apples or oranges?’ this would be my answer but it’s certainly on the list.

I can’t remember the very first time I heard ‘Telegraph Road’ but I would’ve been young. It would have been on the cassette of Dire Straits song that my dad had in his car which, in turn, had been put together by his friend from the LPs. Telegraph Road had a tiny scratch on it. I know this to be the case rather than a blip in the tape because when that family friend was killed and the LPs became my dad’s – the scuff at “I’ve seen desperation” meant it forever jumped to “see it again.” A tiny detail but one that’s etched as clear in my memory as it is on the wax.

That means that – basing this on the passing of the aforementioned family friend – I’ve been hooked on this song for nearly four decades. It could explain where my love of a slow-burn, building song comes from. Hell you could even extrapolate further to whether that, in turn, was where my lean toward post-rock and its structures of multifaceted songs that rise and fall and span nearly quarter of an hour comes from. Either way, ‘Telegraph Road’ and I go way back.

Nearly quarter of an hour… 14 minutes and 18 seconds to be precise. Cosied up with ‘Private Investigations’ on side one of Dire Straits’ finest record Love Over Gold. This epic came to Knopfler (and is also his second song in this series) while sat in the front of a tour bus driving down the actual Telegraph Road – a 70 mile route in Michigan – and happened to be reading Growth of the Soil, Knut Hamsun’s novel about a man who finds a patch of soil in rural Norway, settles down and sets up his home. Mark Knopfler put the two together has he travelled down the road that “just went on and on and on forever, it’s like what they call linear development … I wondered how that road must have been when it started, what it must have first been like … I just put that book together and the place where I was. I was actually sitting in the front of the tour bus at the time.”

Across the song, Knopfler narrates the rise, fall, consumption by modernity – as that track becomes a six-lane monster – and collapse of Telegraph Road (a proxy for Detroit) but it’s the way in which his story is so beautifully synched to the arrangement that makes ‘Telegraph Road’ so magical for me. It starts of with a simple, single note before gradually building up in terms of both instrumentation (it’s nearly a minute before Knopfler’s resonator guitar arrives) and melody. The main theme starts close to two minutes in. There are thunder claps in there, brilliant drumming from Pick Withers (this song would be his last recording for the band) particularly with the explosive hit after ‘then there was a war.’ Knopfler’s guitar work builds apace and lets go in two terrific solos.

There is no realistic way for me to put an estimate on the number of times I’ve heard ‘Telegraph Road’. Much like Dark Side of the Moon it’s one of those musical marks in my life that seems to have been ever present. What I do know is that no matter what that number is, whenever it comes on shuffle in the car I still listen transfixed throughout and that my copy of Love Over Gold (which doesn’t jump the ‘..explode into flames, and I..’ part) has had many a spin. I can also say that their recent remastering campaign means listening to it again on a good pair of headphones is pretty amazing. Whether that means that this song is the one I’d choose to be the only song I can listen to again… well, that’s still undecided but it’s definitely a contender.

Love Over Gold, Dire Strait’s fourth (and best) album was their last to feature original drummer Pick Withers who felt the band was becoming too loud and wanted to get off the treadmill. Rhythm guitarist David Knopfler had already left under less pleasant circumstances. As such Love Over Gold serves as a transitional record for the band as the last of the original members were augmented by new players including Alan Clark on keyboards as Knopfler’s compositions grew in scope and the band evolved into that which would go on to record Brothers In Arms, trot around stadiums around the world, taking a break, coming back to do it all again one more time with On Every Street before Knopfler decided that maybe Pick Withers was right – it was all getting a bit loud and time to get off. Dire Straits have sold an estimated 120 million records, been inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame (whatever that really means) but are exceedingly unlikely to reunite.

I fear that I’m ordinary, just like everyone – Five From The Smashing Pumpkins

I’ve been spending a lot of time with The Smashing Pumpkins’ music recently. To be more specific, that of their first ‘run’. You know, that glorious period captured on Rotten Apples from 1991 thru 2000. My wife – in true enabler fashion – got a bit trigger happy in Rough Trade last year when she saw the Melon Collie And The Infinite Sadness box and, with a couple of purchases since their albums to that point now sit in my record collection and indulged in a plenty.

Never knowingly non-grandiose, there was always something different about Smashing Pumpkins that stood them apart from the pack in that golden era of alt. rock in the early nineties. There’s wasn’t the raw angst of those bands hailing from the Pacific North West, instead they proffered a more richly layered and often, well, fucking gorgeous sound propelled by the distinctive voice and brilliant guitar work of Billy Corgan. The rest of the band – James Iha, Jimmy Chamberlain and D’arcy Wretzky – always looked cool as hell while Corgan maintained the look of someone apart. I was chatting about the band this weekend with the owner of my record store of choice and he maintains that Billy, while alway a bit weird, went full-on knobhead when he shaved off his hair. I think he has a point.

So, harkening back to a time when he was just a bit of a pretentious control-freak rather than full-on David Icke supporting lunatic, I thought I’d drop five examples of tunes from that period they could do no wrong while steering clear of the obvious, but still great, choices of ‘Today’, ‘Tonight, Tonight’, ‘Disarm’ etc. It’s also worth pointing out first that ‘Mayonaise’ remains the single best thing they’ve put to tape but having already blogged about that, I won’t do so again here.

Bury Me

First album Gish is full of absolute belters of which ‘Bury Me’ is a great example of the band’s harder side – delivering pummelling riffs that would be at home on a Soundgarden album underpinned with Corgan’s innate ability to unleash a guitar solo and drop down to a nagging melody and expansiveness of sound inside of four and a half minutes.

Drown

Eight and a bit minutes of brilliance complete with feedback and an E-Bow solo, on an already unimpeachable collection, ‘Drown’ felt like an outlier then on the Seattle-focused Singles soundtrack and still feels like one today in the same way as Paul Westerberg’s cuts. It is, however, a massive early highlight. It was written after Gish and serves as a bridge between that album and their next. Due to label politics – Alice In Chains etc were on Epic as was the soundtrack – it was never released as a single despite radio love. Second only to Mayoinaise for me.

Soma

A rare Corgan / Iha co-write, ‘Soma’ is the centrepiece of Siamese Dream – a six and a half minute song that manages to encapsulate every characteristic of the band’s sound, managing to move from the tender to ferocious with a dynamic few could muster.

Starla

They’d only released two studio album when Pisces Iscariot arrived in 1994 as a collection of B-sides and previously unreleased songs to demonstrate that The Smashing Pumpkins had tunes to spare before we even knew what 1995 would bring. With songs that are almost as strong as those released as many already released, Pisces Iscariot is that rarest of things – an ‘odds and sods’ album that’s nearly essential. ‘Starla’ is an 11-minute epic that should be entered as evidence that Corgan was one of the era’s greatest rock guitarists.

Muzzle

How to choose a song from the behemoth that is Melon Collie And The Infinite Sadness? A 28 song double album with very little filler… One of the most ambitious and indulgent albums out there, a slab of great music that’s stocked to folds with tunes songs including ‘Tonight, Tonight’, ‘1979’, ‘Zero’, ‘Bullet with Butterfly Wings’, ‘Thirty Three’, ‘Porcelina Of The Vast Oceans’….. well, I really like ‘Muzzle’ so let’s go with that.

We watch the world from the padded cell: Dead Man’s Pop and The Replacements’ revision of history

You know I get the feeling that Paul Westerberg has quietly retired from music. It would be a real shame if that’s the case, he’s a massively over-looked songwriter of particular skill both across his extensive solo catalogue and, most famously, with The Replacements.

Despite Westerberg’s songwriting chops and the band’s impact on their fans, many of whom would go on to form their own bands and achieve the level of success that eluded The Replacements during their initial run from 1979-1991. Many a pontification has already been made about why that break-through success always seemed, if you will, within their reach never occurred. Was it bad timing? Was it their own self-destructive tendencies?

It could be all of those things but more likely, as Westerberg would surmise in an interview to promote their temporary 2015 reunion and string of shows: “It was reprehensible some of the things they wanted us to do that were supposed to make our career bigger and ultimately make them the money. I swear to God we tried several times to get in line with that and we just couldn’t do it. Our personalities would not allow us to do that thing.”

That’s not to say that, toward the end, they didn’t try after all. Signed to Sire in 1985, their third record for the label Don’t Tell A Soul was a clear attempt at making The Replacments ‘hit’ – presumably at this point the execs were shouting louder than the fans. I’ve always had a lot of time for Don’t Tell A Soul – it contains some of their finest songs and is another clear jump in Westerberg’s songwriting evolution. For the first time they played it ‘straight’ across a whole album and there’s a notable shift toward more a mature take on subject matter.

The problem with Don’t Tell A Soul, though, wasn’t the songs. It lay in the sound. As per seemingly all their releases to date, The Replacements had…. issues with finding the right producer. In this case it was original producer Tony Berg being swapped out for Matt Wallace. Then, as if that wasn’t enough, the record company decided to give the tapes to a chap called Chris Lord-Alge to mix. Chris, in his wisdom, decided to give The Replacements a cavernous, overly lacquered mix that swamped the songs in FM wash and robbed made them sound dated almost as soon as the album hit shelves.

If there were a prison for musical crimes, Chris Lord-Alge would still be serving time for his massacre of Don’t Tell A Soul‘s songs. While I’ve always had a soft spot for this album it’s always been hard to get past the poor mixing of great songs like, say, ‘Inherit The Earth’ (from which the album’s title is taken).

Thankfully, though, we no longer have to. The critical and, relative, commercial success of the Rhino release of For Sale: Live at Maxwell’s made that label release that there was still a love and hunger for archival Replacements material – Dead Man’s Pop arrived in 2019 and is a vital piece of the puzzle.

Yes, there’s the usual live recording and outtakes discs (pretty much everything recording during the Don’t Tell a Soul sessions including tracks with a visiting – and drunk – Tom Waits) that typically accompany such a release but what makes Dead Man’s Pop such a regular play for me is that it features the Matt Wallace mix of the album, restored as intended at the time and original sequencing.

With Lord-Alge’s studio bodging stripped from its songs, Don’t Tell a Soul becomes nothing short of a revelation for Replacements fans. It feels rawer and moodier than Pleased To Meet Me but its force places it close to Tim while the subject matter and streamlined songwriting clearly mark it as the work of a more mature band that are clearly pushing forward.

It still retains the ragged beauty that you’d associate with the band, if anything the removal of the studio glitter has revealed more that that. ‘Talent Show’ now begins with behind-the-scenes noise and the band chatting and laughing as they tune their equipment.

This human element, an earthier quality to the mix and sound, is on show throughout the album. The effect is that these songs suddenly sound more natural and organic compared to their previous incarnations, even to the point that the overtly FM-sounding songs like ‘Back to Back’ suddenly feel like they come from the same band that made ‘Bastards of Young’, just one that’s reaching for a higher place musically.

For me the version of Don’t Tell A Soul revealed as part of this box set has been highly addictive – even if it’s taken me so long to write about it. I’d never felt the songs got the attention or credit they deserved but thanks to this recasting the album has been removed from the mists of the late ’80s swamp and given a sound that no longer kneecaps some of their best songs. As bassist Tommy Stinson puts it: “maybe we’ll now sound like a band that stood the test of time.”

If you haven’t heard Don’t Tell A Soul in a while, or at all, do yourself a favour and wrap your lugholes around Dead Man’s Pop.