“This song is about… uh… people who don’t have taste but they like us anyway. It’s called ‘Not For You'”
If Vs. was the sound of Pearl Jam taking control, Vitalogy, released just a year later, is the sound of the band giving a big middle finger to anyone who hand’t got the message yet. Rougher, rawer and more eclectic than anything they’d either released to date or since with songs born out of jam sessions as the communication between band members started to falter, with “eighty percent of the songs were written 20 minutes before they were recorded” according to Stone Gossard. It’s stripped down, it’s lean and uncompromising and marks the first time Pearl Jam would really start to experiment. It’s rife with hostility and tension aimed both outward and inward as, three albums in, cracks began to show within relationships to the point that, while Gossard thought of quitting, drummer Dave Abbruzzese would actually be let go as sessions wound down.
Again – it shouldn’t be good. It shouldn’t be cohesive but it’s not only good: it’s their finest album yet – in my opinion and this is my Least to Most after all. As 1993 tumbled into 1994, Pearl Jam were hitting their songwriting peak and the songs on Vitalogy bristle with an energy that wouldn’t be matched again for a while and certainly not with the level of consistency found here.
The songs here form the template for all Pearl Jam songs to come – there’s the balls-out angry and heavy, there’s the flexing of creative / experimental muscle, the achingly poignant and the perfect mid-tempo. All summised in one rough-hewn gem of an album.
So – you want the balls-out angry and fast? Take that opening volley of songs:’Last Exit’, ‘Spin the Black Circle’ and ‘Not For You’:
As middle fingers to the label go, Pearl Jam chose ‘Spin the Black Circle’, much to Epic’s dismay, as the first single from Vitalogy. “See this needle, Oh see my hand, Drop, drop, dropping it down, oh so gently, here it comes, touch the flame, turn me up, won’t turn you away” is an homage to vinyl and was supposed to sound completely different – it’s a Stone Gossard riff that Vedder first heard at the wrong pitch: “I had come up with something in my truck with the tape player in my hand, but then I realized it was playing at a superhigh pitch. I turned it down, and it was really slow. I was like ‘Oh, fuck.”
‘Not for You’, meanwhile is as openly blunt and angry about the co-opting of the alternative scene as the band would be – save for the time Jeff Ament spotted Marc Jacobs and Anna Sui (who had released a ‘grunge’ line of clothes) and “I went down and did a fake fashion twirl and went ‘Hey Marc, what do you think of this for the next line?’ ” It’s hard to comprehend now in a way but I guess when Ricky Martin is cast on General Hospital as a clone of you – you’re gonna get pissed off. It also burns through ‘Corduroy’ (perfect mid-tempo) with it’s line “they can buy but can’t put on my clothes”:
Both ‘Not for You’ and ‘Corduroy’ are sole Vedder compositions. Vitalogy – dipping back to those inner band tensions mentioned – marked the first Pearl Jam album where Vedder’s songs would by far outweigh those of the other members. Half of the songs here (you can’t really count ‘Aye Davanita’ or ‘Hey Foxymophandlemama, That’s Me’ as songs) are marked as Vedder / Vedder on the lyrics / music front.
Vedder’s “it wasn’t a hostile takeover” caused issues in the group. Stone Gossard was said to have considered leaving as he was no longer the guy who made the final decisions on tunes and vacated his role as mediator within the group (something which Dave Abbruzzese has credited to his departure). With hindsight Jeff Ament has stated that it was simply a case that Vedder was working harder at writing songs than the rest of the band – McCready would enter rehab to receive treatment for alcohol and cocaine abuse during sessions too. “I still don’t know if he was consciously exerting wanting to take over the band or take the reins or the the power. I think it was more like, ‘Hey, man, I’ve got seven complete songs here. What do you guys have?’ and we only had little riffs or two-parter things.”
Of those Vedder / Vedder songs are the achingly poignant Immortality and, of course, one of the band’s most well known:
I’ve probably heard this song live on the numerous shows I have in my iTunes. These days when it’s played live it’s not really the same song but the original is still an out and out classic especially considering its troubled and lengthy gestation as a Pearl Jam studio song. Vedder, fearing it was too raw and direct in terms of emotion, was never happy with how it had been recorded (the band had first tried getting it on tape for Vs.) and, at one point, came close to giving it to Chrissie Hynde to record instead. As it is he changed the final mix for ‘Betterman’ right at the last.
The creative: perhaps too wary of releasing quite so many obviously strong and high-pedigree songs on one album, Pearl Jam used Vitalogy to drop some of their, frankly, weirdest shit to date too. So, following up the beautiful Ament / Vedder collab, ‘Nothingman’…
… is ‘Pry To’
While what could have been a one-two-punch knockout of ‘Betterman’ and ‘Immortality’ is softened by the slotting of ‘Aye Davanita’ between them – it’s “just screwing around” with chanted non-lyrics that O’Brien looped. Then again, there’s something charming about ‘Bugs’ which Vedder, suffering from poison at the time, plays an off-tune accordion.
Then again, perhaps I’m overthinking it. Maybe they really just did like those interludes. But let’s look at it this way: if Vitalogy had been stripped of those and released as a ten track album comprising of songs like ‘Corduroy’, ‘Betterman’, ‘Nothingman’, ‘Last Exit’, ‘Spin the Black Circle’ etc… even with the lean produciton behind them, there’d have been no real way for them to get away from it or say no so easily.
As it is, glorious rough-hewn warts and all, Vitalogy is my favourite Pearl Jam album.
8 thoughts on “Least to Most: Pearl Jam – Vitalogy”
I’d be lying if I said I love this album — but I definitely see your point of Pearl Jam rejecting the mainstream here. Spin The Black Circle is an absolute claseeek but I just can’t over Bugs if I’m honest haha. Nice review!
There’s just something about the attitude and posture of this record that makes it so good. As you said, the middle finger to those who hadn’t gotten the message yet. Of course, songs like Bugs might be considered by some to be intentionally making things bad to get rid of people and shun media fondness. It just makes clear that they weren’t about having pop hits. Eddie’s now-infamous grammy speech underscores it all the more.
It’s my second favourite behind No Code – Vedder takes them in a punk direction here, which I’m more interested in than arena rock or grunge. Lots of people my age only like their first two albums though.
The bulk of this is exceptional, but it’s those diversions on the second half of the album that have always prevented this from being my favourite. The songs are some of their best. Without a doubt.
Well, firstly, nice series. I could not have written this without a ton of research. I like these guys but I am not a huge fan so my knowledge is limited. I guess if I have one big takeaway it’s how sad and predictable the arc of all these bands is. They all want fame and fortune, then some guy’s a jerk so they throw him out, then they all fight and they all want to quit, then jealousies, and then sometimes guys never talk again. (Especially brothers.)
Good album here except for a couple of oddities. (I actually kinda liked ‘Aye Davenita.) Some good, crunchy rock. I suppose once upon a time I would have said ‘Ten’ was my favorite of their albums but I’m kinda tired of that one. So, hey, where’s the master Spotify list?
I told you I have a PJ take coming up. This was in the running when i drew straws. Love the music on this. You educated me on many things I didn’t and would ever know. Good piece from a true fan. I love rock hard albums and this is one.
Thanks, CB. Looking forward to your take
Pingback: Albums of my years – 1994 | Mumbling About…