Here we go then – down the last five, the cream of the crop, the Harrisons of the group, the Toxic Twins’ most… toxic? Aerosmith’s top five albums in my Least to Most favourite order:
I’m trying to avoid repeating what’s either well-documented or common knowledge at this point but it’s impossible to mention Permanent Vacation without mentioning that this Aerosmith’s big, balls-out, no holds barred attempt at a comeback after both the disappointing reaction and sales garnered by their first album for Geffen, Done With Mirrors.
Between the two albums lay both an unexpectedly massive cross-over hit courtesy of their Run-DMC and getting clean – a process well documented with Tyler and Perry’s books along with the band’s ‘Walk This Way’ detailing the process in surprisingly open detail for those interested.
That means Permanent Vacation was the first time the band recorded free of any drugs – they were already baby-stepping their way in on their first – and clearly working hard to get back to the top.
There are negatives to this album – the over-wrought production courtesy of Bruce Fairbairn, the plethora of outside songwriters (apparently Holly Knight’s sole contribution was changing ‘Rag Time’ to ‘Rag Doll’ – bing, bang, boom ‘hit’ and songwriting-credit)… but, but BUT. I slipped this cd into the car for the first time in a while recently and it’s still a fucking fun record. It positively stinks of fun. Maybe we don’t need to hear ‘Dude (Looks Like A Lady)’ again (especially in 2022) and the cover of ‘I’m Down’ is as pointless as a chocolate fireguard, but the album works, especially the non-singles like ‘Hearts Done Time’ (written by Perry and Desmond Child while Tyler was finishing rehab), ‘Hangman Jury’ and ‘Girl Keeps Coming Apart’ are a blast to listen to. It’s a perfectly-wrapped time capsule to 1987 when a newly invigorated Aerosmith were back on form and rediscovering the joy of making music.
Get Your Wings
Unhappy with the way album number one turned out in terms of sound and sales (no promotion, no airplay, no interviews etc), Aerosmith went at it hard for their second. Get Your Wings‘ recording was preceded by intense rehearsals and pre-production refining of songs that had begun taking shape on the road. And while Get Your Wings may initially have met a similar fate in the sales department (though it would go on to sell a few million) it was not only reviewed more widely but met positive reviews. With due reason: it’s on Get Your Wings that Aerosmith not only hit its stride but, with Jack Douglas manning the boards, managed to get the capturing of that sound right too.
Get Your Wings, then, contains some of their best songs – ‘Same Old Song and Dance’ (I’ve still not found an explanation why Joe Perry didn’t play the lead on the record’s version or ‘Train Kept A Rollin’ – in fact he plays very little lead on this one) and ‘Seasons of Wither’ should sit high on anyone’s lists – and is one of their finest moments. Still relatively fresh out of the gates as a band, the song-writing is coming together brilliantly and the band – tighter now from a lot of touring to push their first album and build their fan-base outside of Boston – bring the goods. This is where they shed the uncertainty of their first album and find the sound and formula that would propel them to the top over the next few years.
Toys In The Attic
If Get Your Wings benefited from the band’s maturation as songwriters and tightness from touring, the jump from touring behind that powered their next, Toys In The Attic even more notably from both the riffs that Brad Whitford and Joe Perry bought back from the road to the confidence they bought with them to performing in the studio.
Without the benefit of having years to work on the songs, Toys In The Attic was Aerosmith starting from scratch and working to a deadline. It worked: along with Perry and Whitford, Tom Hamilton bought two songs to the table and while I can take or leave ‘Uncle Salty’ I defy anyone to crank up ‘Sweet Emotion’ and not get a kick from it. Meanwhile ‘Toys In The Attic’, ‘Walk This Way’, ‘No More No More’ and even ‘You See Me Crying’ (in all its 70’s rock extravagance) rank among their finest songs and, with Jack Douglas now adapt at capturing the band’s sound and energy, Toys In The Attic was Aerosmith’s breakthrough and it still holds up as a cracker today.
Interesting (probably not very) side-note: Run-DMC thought the name of the band was Toys In The Attic and the album that was home to ‘Walk This Way’ was called Aerosmith.
Why is Pump number 2 on this list? Because it’s so fucking good, that’s why. It’s the highlight of their second charge – it may not have hit the same sales figures as Get A Grip did but where that album felt bloated, Pump is taught at ten tracks. You can tell this is before the era of cd-bloat as ‘The Other Side’ meant ‘Deuces Are Wild’ was canned rather than expanded to eleven tracks.
There’s a massive leap between Permanent Vacation and Pump – the band don’t sound lost in the production sheen that coated their comeback album, instead they’re positively flexing in it and sounding, well, pumped up.
There are less outside co-writes, the songs revel in their amped-up sound and on Pump the gritty, raunch-n-blues of Aerosmith’s peak is incorporated into the mix and the band are clearly powerfully focused as though to prove the point that their comeback was no fluke and they could still bring the good without song doctors – Tyler and Perry had a hand on 7 of the 10 tracks, there’s a Tyler/Whitford and Tyler / Hamilton song here and only 4 of the tracks feature non-band writers. In comparison twelve of Get A Grip‘s fourteen songs featured outside writers and the band alone were responsible for only three of Permanent Vacation‘s songs.
Everything on this album sounds right – even with all the extra horns and synths of the era ‘The Other Side’ rocks hard, ‘Young Lust’ is as good an opener as they’ve done and ‘What It Takes’ is the only of their ballads worth tuning in – it’s also the only one on the album really.
Despite the cringe-worthy Spinal Tap-isms that abounded on ‘The Making of Pump’ – this is the sound of a band firing on every cylinder. They were clean and they were tighter than a duck’s arse again after a massive tour in support of Permanent Vacation – this is only real instance where they managed to combine the ‘hit making’ formula that pervaded their later career with the best of their ‘vintage’ and it worked – great songs, great performances and not an ounce of fat.
It couldn’t really be anything else that sits at the top of the pile here but Rocks. This is the quintessential Aerosmith album – it’s the sound of them at their utter peak, managing to capture their rawest, hardest album full of great songs even in the face of massive quantities of drugs being ingested like they were training for the snortolympics.
‘Back In The Saddle’, ‘Last Child’, ‘Rats in the Cellar’, ‘Nobody’s Fault’, ‘Lick and a Promise’… not only is Rocks stuffed with more great songs than anything else they’ve done but it works as a start-to-finish album too. I mean, you’d have to be off your tits on something to come up with all the details of ‘Back In The Saddle’ – the ‘heeya’ calls and fucking hoof beats, the actual whip cracks (which were abandoned after multiple bloody attempts yielded a shit sound so replaced by whipping a microphone cord and using cap gun – as if this were the more sensible route), Tyler taping tambourines to his boots and stomping around the studio, Perry playing a six-string bass like a guitar and the yodels on the fade-out… and yet it’s fucking glorious because of all that and because it’s all underpinned by the sound of the band at their peak – screaming leads, absolute power from the rhythm and Tyler giving it all in the name of the song. Which, as it turns out, is as good a summary of the whole album as you could get from me.
8 thoughts on “Least to Most: Aerosmith, Part 3”
Top 5 is great. You like Pump a little more than me but I get it. It’s a good album. Toys is my favorite then Rock. I think that was my top 2 on my list.
As I said on an earlier post, I should try out Rocks sometime – the songs I like best (apart from Dream On) on the greatest hits are from that.
After doing my ‘Greatest Debut Albums’ post I did something I’ve never done before – take one artist and listen to his albums all the way through. For my first endeavor, I chose Elvis Costello. I know his stuff pretty well but there were huge gaps in my knowledge. There were some albums where I knew maybe one or two tunes. And I was amazed how relatively quickly he went from that angry punk to a melodic tunesmith. Anybody checking in starting with the early 80s would barely recognize the 70s guy. I’m up to 1993’s “The Juliet Letters” with the Brodsky Quartet. As far from punk as you can get and actually, surprisingly, it works.
I mention all this because I’m going to have to do the same thing with Aerosmith. I know all the hits but the deep cuts, not so much.
As to the “Train Kept A’ Rolling’ thing, I’d never heard that about Perry. Did a little research. Firstly Wikipedia says that Steve Hunter did the first solo, and Dick Wagner did the second. These guys were cream of the crop and if you read between the lines in some of the articles, Perry wasn’t yet up to the task. As you doubtless know it’s not at all uncommon for producers to pull in other talents when the band isn’t up to it for one reason or another. It’s all done very quietly and nobody gets hurt. And remember, this was only Aerosmith’s second album so Perry needed some seasoning. I never thought he was one of he greats but I recently learned his solos for ‘Walk This Way’ and they’re very clever.
I think listening to them in order would be great an interesting take, there are definite peaks and troughs that seem to flow through each of the decades.
Great article too – Wagner also played the solo on Same Old Song and Dance. A while back I saw The Making of Pump (which would make you think This Is Spinal Tap had never been released) and there was a big argument between Tyler and Joey Kramer who was struggling to get a drum part right (or ‘right’ in the ears of Tyler). There was talk of either using a programmed sound or getting someone else to do it in the studio. Even knowing how the arguing over drum sounds had gone on for years and lead to Kramer’s breakdown in the late 90s it’s still an eye opener. I mention this here as while in ’89 they had both the time to do so and experience to know they could get the part right themselves, fifteen years earlier it probably wasn’t the case so “get someone else in for the record and work on it on the road.”
That’s right. Forgot about that. Tyler is a drummer and wanted stuff played his way. Didn’t realize it had gotten that bad. I know he’s had some falling out with the band and his position was tenuous at best.
Kramer’s wife just died a couple months ago. He’s not touring with them in 2022. Unclear if that’s due to bad blood or if he’s laying low.
That’s a real shame. I wonder if he’d announced his leave of absence due to her health?
There is undoubtedly bad blood: he was sidelined by injury for much of 2019 and the rest of the group refused to let him back in, all the while he had to pay his replacement – he ended up filing a lawsuit to get back in only for Covid to stop the show. It’s the more of a business than a band these days it seems
Actually I think it’s true of all bands, for good or for ill that they are a business. It always seems to come down to “you only give me your funny papers.”
Meant to add this