And wherever we might go: Pearl Jam’s ‘Lost Years’ 2000-2005 (Part One)

In February 1998 Pearl Jam released Yield. It marked something of a comeback for them; it was more straight-ahead than the wilfully restrained No Code, saw the band release their first music video since 1992 and, with the Ticket Master battle lost, marked a return to full-scale touring (documented on Live On Two Legs, released that November). At one sound check that autumn they recorded a song for that year’s fan club Christmas single*. When it began picking up airplay on radio the following year Pearl Jam’s cover of ‘Last Kiss’ soon went into heavy rotation and ended up hitting No. 2 on the charts, giving them their biggest hit to date.

They ‘d be entitled to take a break at this point, to catch their breath and attend to life off the road but then at this point they hadn’t quite learnt how to do that** and they carried on into the new millennium and a period which would see acclaim and sales diminish further than they had with the release of No Code and events that nearly marked the end of the band.

As companies the world over and religious sects and cults realised that the ticking of the clock into a new millennium meant neither massive technological meltdowns, raptures or Armageddons weren’t happening, all was not well in the Pearl Jam camp. The band’s not-so-secret weapon Mike McCready was battling addiction to painkillers and sessions for Binaural were marked by his absence as well as Eddie Vedder – who, though intensely guarded about his personal life, was experiencing both the worst case of writer’s block he’d encountered and divorce. As such, Vedder has since referred to the recording of Binaural as being “a construction job”.

Perhaps they should have taken that break. I mean, after all, Binaural shifted less than Yield and has still to make the million mark and Riot Act has still moved less than half of what Vs shifted in its first five days alone. Are they that bad? No, in short, they’re not. In fact I’m here to argue that for both the uninitiated and the initiated (I still know Pearl Jam fans that haven’t listened to Riot Act), there’s some real gems to be found in this era.

I’ll hold up Binaural‘s first single ‘Nothing As It Seems’ as an example. Written by  bass player Jeff Ament, it started as a very dry, basic demo. He took it to McCready and told him that for the song to happen, the guitarist would need to go to town on it. He did.

Now perhaps I am a little biased in my views as Binaural was the first ‘new’ Pearl Jam release since I’d gotten into the band but I do love this song and while it’s most definitely a headphone album (thanks to the binaural recording technique you’ll need both buds in), live this one, like so many others, comes into its own and McCready’s work on it is guaranteed a rapturous response.

For my money – and I remember the surprised face on the tube on the way to see the band at Wembley when I voiced this opinion to those I was travelling with – Binaural is very much a second-half album. The faster songs that open it don’t quite suit the recording technique even with Brendan O’Brien’s mixing efforts but the second half, from ‘Light Years’ (itself a lovely song and one I’m always surprised by when it comes up on playlists – ‘how could I forget this one?’) on contains some of the juiciest things the band have put to tape.

Insignificance‘ is up there with ‘Corduroy’ as one of the band’s best mid-tempo rockers and I remember it ripping the roof off Wembley Arena. ‘Soon Forget’ marked the introduction of Vedder’s ukulele and cleared his writer’s block, ‘Of The Girl‘ – which started out as a bluesy riff from Stone – is the best use of the binaural recording technique on the album and ‘Sleight of Hand’, a mediation on being stuck in a routine and dissatisfied with one’s life,  is the realisation of the band’s most art-rock aspirations with its effects and wall-of-sound blasts in the chorus:

In hindsight the band have come to regard Binaural as an album marked by distractions and missed opportunities, a lack of focus that meant the album lacked the power it could have had. Gossard, for his part, feels that they should’ve gotten more out of new drummer Matt Cameron – “It should have devastated in a way that Temple of the Dog devastated”. They just weren’t writing with him in mind. Jeff Ament goes further, believing that in cutting songs like ‘Sad’ and ‘Education’ “we look back and think we didn’t put some of the best songs on it.”

Indeed – released later on Lost Dogs – songs from the sessions like ‘Fatal‘, ‘Education’ ‘Sad’ would certainly have added a different angle to the album than, say, ‘God’s Dice’.

Upon release  Binaural was received pretty favourably by the press and while the sales weren’t what they were used to be and radio had already shifted what little focus it had given the band to acts incorporating the scratch of turntables into rock, Pearl Jam did what they’ve always done – headed out onto the road. A tour of North America was lined up but, first, they’d venture to Europe to play a series of arena shows – I caught them when they played Wembley in May –  and festivals including Pinkpop in the Netherlands and to Denmark to play the Roskilde festival.

During ‘Daughter’ the 50,000 strong crowd continued to surge forward. The band had made many a plea for the crowd to take a step back and, realising something was wrong, stopped playing. “It was chaos,” Vedder has said. “Some people were yelling ‘thank you.’ Others, who weren’t in bad shape, were running up and saying ‘hi.’ Then someone was pulled over, laid out and they were blue. We knew immediately it had gone on to that other level.”

Eight young men aged between 17 and 25 had been killed in the crush and bodies were being passed over the barricades as the band and fans stood and watched in horror. A ninth man would die in hospital five days later.

The remainder of the European tour was cancelled and, not knowing how to move forward, the members of Pearl Jam considered retiring. 


*Since 1991 the band have released a fan-club-only single every holiday season (with the exception of 1994)

**When Jack Irons joined the band he was both impressed and surprised by their work ethic. Work on No Code had kicked off during a heat wave and immediately after a massive show. Iron’s was understandably knackered and, frankly, fancied a rest. The band didn’t yet know the importance of doing so and were too keen to keep pushing forward with the momentum and energy of the tour.

18 thoughts on “And wherever we might go: Pearl Jam’s ‘Lost Years’ 2000-2005 (Part One)

  1. This was a great read! I’m a Pearl Jam fan (passed down from my dad!) and there were some really interesting facts in this – will definitely be adding a few of these songs to my playlist

  2. Binaural being the first new record since you started following the band… we have something in common there. I was too young to follow the early days, and then I was raised largely on Christian music and it wasn’t until high school I started branching out and filling myself in on the wider culture that I’d been ignorant of. Maybe that has something to do with the fact that I enjoyed Binaural and Riot Act more than a lot of fans. I definitely agree that B-sides like “Fatal” and “Education” might have made it slightly stronger, but I also think there are some real underrated tracks there. “Rivals” and “Grievance” are great tunes.
    It’s a good insight that they may not have been writing with Cameron in mind. In fact, I think Riot act saw them taking steps that way. Thanks for writing.

    • Well, I almost bought Yield upon release based on the reviews but when I took the case to the till they’d sold out. I bought OK Computer instead so Live On Two Legs was my first ‘new’ release, I picked it up when it was released when I read a review that called it “Arse Quaking” and got Ten and Yield at the same time so the three were my entry point.
      Riot Act is up next.

  3. I’ll give the Spotify list a spin for sure. ‘Last Kiss?’ An oldie from the Indispensable years. Not one of my favorites, frankly. I couldn’t even understand why they did it. But what do I know? Pretty big hit.

    • They usually do an unusual cover or a sort of improv type thing for the fan-club single and EdVed had found a copy of the original in an antique place in Seattle. The flip side of this one was a cover of “Soldier of Love (Lay Down Your Arms)”, I don’t think it was ever intended for mass release. An accidental hit really

      • PJ’s Ten Club is pretty intense. I’m toying with the idea based on the exclusives and presales. The band are very much involved, it’s just that little extra really for the hardcore.
        Back some two decades ago I joined the Aerosmith one briefly – only benefit there was getting presale and cheap tickets to their Wembley Stadium gig.

      • Yeah, one needs an inside edge these days for the top bands. For the most part, I’ve checked out of the big concert scene. Might still see a few but spending more time at the small clubs these days.

      • A different time, alas. This will take time to unravel but my prediction is that all this will lead to impeachment by this time next year and he will then resign. And a few people will go to jail. And good riddance.

      • BTW, now I can’t get ‘Last Kiss’ out of my head. Even played it on guitar for fun. Chords are G-Emin-C-D. Thanks, mate! 😂

  4. I am not very familiar with this album. I listened to about half of it and I thought it was terrific. Love the guitar on ‘Nothing As It Seems’ and ‘Breakerfall’ is, as you would say, cracking. Look forward to the rest.

  5. Pingback: Least to Most: Pearl Jam – Binaural | Mumbling About…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s